| Author |
Message |
| Hopzy |
 Posted: 15-2-2012 11:25 Post subject: |
|
| Sorry for wasting your time, i would like to remove this application. I'm sorry if I've wasted your time. |
|
 |
| Eluniel |
| Posted: 15-2-2012 6:53 Post subject: |
|
Gala has a point. Faction change is kind of commitment, but still it doesn't neglect our rules. How about being social member and part of Peter's 10-man group at the start? That could be a nice start and opportunity to see alliance side & FE? I know it is still not main... but it is his alliance main? XD
I will leave this case to Jodie... after all it is her decision. |
|
|
| Galadruin the Dwarf |
| Posted: 15-2-2012 5:41 Post subject: |
|
Couple of key points (Some mentioned)
Professions: So many good ones that benefit you, certainly Blacksmith for extra 2 gem sockets is great.
www.noxxic.com is a good website with sound advice on all classes.
A key point we are missing is the chap is willing to Faction Change to join which is a fair commitment as a starter. |
|
|
| Sherawr |
| Posted: 15-2-2012 5:25 Post subject: |
|
Sorry in the delay in my response. As the guilds MT and only raiding deathknight I feel the comments of my piers above have pretty much covered all bases from gems to glyphs and talents choices. I personally am not going to waste much time, as if you aren't going to be transferring across your main, and cannot commit to the full raiding schedule for the trial period then I seriously doubt that your app will be accepted.
GL in the future |
|
|
| Hopzy |
| Posted: 15-2-2012 4:07 Post subject: |
|
| The gems and enchants have been fixed. Well some of them aren't what Mr robot suggest but at least they are now dps versions. |
|
|
| Jarakuel / Chris |
| Posted: 15-2-2012 3:47 Post subject: DK app |
|
Not sure if i'm the only one that has noticed it or not, but he has no professions. To me thats a big loss in dps / money making abilities (to better gear etc.). To me it just seems as though he's not making the effort to make his character the best it can be. Some of the gems are confusing, using hybrid gems that don't even give the socket bonus for example??? Also some of your enchants aren't even dps enchants. I think that if you took everybody's comments into consideration, you'd stand a very good chance of being accepted into the guild, including the comments about 100% attendance needed (even mondays). Good luck with your application to the guild, as it stands now it's a no from me, but if you make these efforts to improve your character then it will change to a yes  . |
|
|
| Hopzy |
| Posted: 15-2-2012 2:27 Post subject: |
|
| My intention was not to apply to the 10man part of the raid too but i wouldn't mind it. |
|
|
| Hopzy |
| Posted: 15-2-2012 2:25 Post subject: |
|
I was on my way of tweaking my spec and I remember'd it was Wednesday  . And I've got a spec for blood at the ready and i will learn that spec and get gear as soon as possible. Regarding my main, I totally understand why you want it and i'm sorry to say that i was only going to consider moving my Death knight and i totally understand if you decline the application for that reason.
Thank you |
|
|
| Tuishao |
| Posted: 15-2-2012 2:20 Post subject: |
|
| Tethane wrote: | | , 10 man is pretend raiding :P |
Yea... Obviously.. Only difference in 10man and 25man is you have less idiots to c**k it up for you, Otherwise 25man would be easy aswell. By what I've seen one shotting every boss in 25man seems easier than getting stuck on warmaster in 10man....... And I do 10man cos I can't make 25man's and its more personal don't have to carry as much people.
Maybe he's applying to join the 10man team as he mentioned that?!
Its a nice application tbh, just need to go tweek your spec and join on your main and it will be fine with me. |
|
|
| Hopzy |
| Posted: 15-2-2012 2:04 Post subject: |
|
| Oh and about the gems/enchants on my gear I really should of looked on Mr Robot and fixed it before i applied, sorry about that. Just the enchants can be sometimes expensive but i'm trying to get the proper enchants as soon as possible. |
|
|
| Hopzy |
| Posted: 15-2-2012 1:55 Post subject: |
|
If there was a change to my main's guild, like the times were no longer available for me i would most likely move to alliance, it seems with the greater population in alliance gives them an advantage on more signup in 25man guilds etc... I didn't know that the guild wasn't doing 10mans too, i must of missed it.
That talent spec was given to my by a friend and i really didn't ask why he did it, and to be honest i'm actually questioning myself on why i didn't notice them two talents and i'm going to change them into something more ... valuable?
The thing about the whole 'i hope my gear will drop' is what keeps me motivated. It's just the way i work, regardless if i don't get it or not. My reaction of someone getting the gear is so what... there's always next time (Remember people have different ways of keeping them motivated in a long raid and this is how i do it). |
|
|
| Cassor |
| Posted: 15-2-2012 1:24 Post subject: |
|
As Jodie says, our 10 man team are non-core raiders who do 10 man for a laugh and to keep them from trouble
I just don't get the sense that you have raided a lot and at the right level on your main, let alone your alt. |
|
|
| Tethane |
| Posted: 14-2-2012 18:36 Post subject: |
|
Well we would like another DK to join our team but we do not accept alts and do require 100% attendance through your trial. I wouldn't be happy to accept anyone that would take a preference in a raid spot with another guild.
As for the "getting over your barrier" comment, we are a pure 25 man Guild 8/8 prenerf and 4th progressed 25 man Guild on the server. In all fairness your lack of experience in 25 man Dragonsoul concerns me, 10 man is pretend raiding :P |
|
|
| Zuruthan |
| Posted: 14-2-2012 17:34 Post subject: |
|
i have a dk alt i play from time to time.
And like thomas had said, why the icy reach?
As a raiding spec i do not see the positive side on this, heck, even prefer Lichborne above that, since u can coilheal yourself in times of need. Or put the points into Improved Frost Presence even.
The rest seems ok, altho, i do not get why u reforge hit from your headpiece, if u then enchant your bracers with hit rating, just a tought...
As for a quote, "i will gladly help u get over this barrier". Seems to me that u place yourself above our guild, and i don't like the attitude of "i hope my gear will drop, i hope my gear will drop"... As a starter u won't be getting all the gear u desire compared to fellow raiders who've been here longer. What would your reaction be towards this?
Your 2nd spec is just a copy of the first, with just a switch between 2h and DW... why is that?
I don't see any benefit from that, why not test out UH?
Or get a tanking offspec, it's allways handy !
But seems like an OK app for the rest .
Just my tought about it ;).
- Zurrrrrrru |
|
|
| Hievna |
| Posted: 14-2-2012 15:10 Post subject: |
|
Why are you using hybrid gems when you could be using 40 str gems?
There is couple of enchants that could be better.
You have too much hit and too little expertise.
I have specced my DK slightly different than you have. Can you explain why you chose them instead of others? Like 2 points in icy reach for example.
Why do you have 2h frost as second spec and not blood or unholy? Have you tried the other two spec?
What race are you planning to change? |
|
|
